← Back to The Haunt Report
IncidentsOct 31, 2026 · 12 min read

Did Houdini Ever Come Back? A Hundred Years of Halloween Séances, from 'Rosabelle, Believe' to Tonight

At twenty-six minutes past one this afternoon, thirteen people will take their seats in a brownstone at 278 West 113th Street in Harlem and ask Harry Houdini to say something. The time is not arbitrary. It is the minute he died in a Detroit hospital room on 31 October 1926, which makes today the exact centenary, and the house is the one he bought in 1904 and filled with locks, props and one of the largest collections of books on magic ever assembled. Two more sittings follow at half past six and half past nine. Across the country a group of magic historians will do the same thing at the Magic Castle in Hollywood, and smaller circles will do it in Scranton, Detroit, Appleton, Chicago, Budapest and a few dozen other places. Nobody expects an answer. That is, in an odd way, the point.

The Houdini séance is the longest-running controlled experiment in the history of the paranormal. It has a pre-registered success criterion, a code agreed in advance between the subject and the person waiting for him. It has had a hundred years, a cash reward, the most motivated witness imaginable and, in 1929, one claimed positive result. This blog has spent two months on the Halloween run-up telling stories where the record and the legend part company. This one is different, because the record is the legend, and the man at the centre of it wrote most of it himself.

What is the Houdini séance?

The Houdini séance is an annual attempt, held on or around 31 October, to receive a message from the escape artist Harry Houdini, who died on Halloween 1926. It began with his widow, Bess, who sat for him for ten years and declared the effort finished in 1936, and it has been continued since by magicians who inherited the tradition from her circle. Two rival lineages now claim it: the Official Houdini Séance, run by the family of the collector Sidney Radner and held in a different city each year, and the Original Houdini Séance at the Houdini Museum in Scranton, Pennsylvania. Neither has ever reported contact.

The test built into it is a ten-word phrase that Houdini and Bess agreed before his death, built on the cipher they had used in their vaudeville mind-reading act. If a medium produced those ten words, it was him. In January 1929 the New York medium Arthur Ford produced them. Within a week the claim was in pieces, and the way it fell apart is the most instructive part of the whole story.

The magician who hunted mediums

Erik Weisz was born in Budapest on 24 March 1874, grew up in Appleton, Wisconsin, and became Harry Houdini, the handcuff king, the man who escaped from everything. By the 1920s he was also the most famous enemy the Spiritualist movement had, and the reason was personal. His mother, Cecilia, died in July 1913 while he was performing in Europe, and he never fully recovered from it. He wanted, very badly, for the mediums to be right.

The friendship that tested that wish was with Arthur Conan Doyle, who by then had given up detective fiction for the cause of spirit communication. On 18 June 1922, at the Ambassador Hotel in Atlantic City, Lady Doyle sat Houdini down and produced, by automatic writing, page after page of loving messages from his mother, headed with the sign of the cross. Houdini said nothing at the time and the Doyles believed he was moved. In December he put his objections in writing: his mother was the wife of a rabbi and would not have signed herself with a cross, and she could not read, write or speak English. The friendship survived the letter and did not survive his book. A Magician Among the Spirits came out in 1924, a catalogue of how slates are written, tables lifted and trumpets floated, and Doyle stopped answering.

That same year Houdini sat on the Scientific American committee that offered a cash prize to any medium who could produce a physical phenomenon under test conditions, and spent the summer in Boston with Mina Crandon, the medium known as Margery, whose bell box rang and whose table tipped in the dark. He built a cabinet that left only her head and hands free, found a folding ruler inside it that could have reached the bell, and published a pamphlet on her methods. The committee never awarded the prize. He also ran what amounted to a private intelligence service. From 1925 his chief investigator, Rose Mackenberg, went into each town a week or so ahead of his tour under names like Frances Raud, collected spirit messages from husbands she had never had, and then sat in the audience while Houdini named the mediums from the stage. She said afterwards that she visited more than a thousand and never met a genuine one.

In February and May 1926 the two of them took it to Washington, where a House subcommittee was considering a bill to ban fortune-telling for money in the District of Columbia. The hearings were a riot. Houdini waved a sealed telegram and challenged anyone in the room to read it; Mackenberg testified that a Washington medium had told her several senators came for readings and that séances had been held at the White House. The bill never reached a vote. He was dead within six months.

Ten days in October

The last tour began to go wrong in Albany on 11 October 1926, when the stocks of the Water Torture Cell twisted as he was hoisted and fractured his left ankle. He finished the show, had the leg splinted and braced, and kept the dates. On 19 October he lectured on fraudulent mediums at McGill University in Montreal and sat down the moment he finished because of the pain. On the afternoon of 22 October he was lying on a couch in his dressing room at the Princess Theatre, having his portrait sketched by a McGill student named Sam Smilovitz, when another student, J. Gordon Whitehead, asked whether it was true he could take any blow to the stomach. Before Houdini had got up or braced himself Whitehead hit him several times. Smilovitz and a third student, Jacques Price, watched it happen.

He went on to Detroit in agony and with a fever that a doctor in Detroit put at 102 degrees. The doctor told him to go to hospital at once. Houdini opened at the Garrick Theatre on 24 October instead, with a temperature of 104, passed out during the first act, was revived and finished the show. Then he went to Grace Hospital, where surgeons removed a ruptured appendix and found peritonitis already established. He died there, with Bess and his brother Theodore at the hospital, at 1:26 pm on Sunday 31 October 1926. He was fifty-two.

Whether the punches caused the appendicitis has been argued for a century, and the honest medical answer is probably not: an appendix does not usually burst because someone hit it, and the inflammation may well have been underway on the couch. The insurance company took sworn statements from Price and Smilovitz and paid Bess double indemnity for accidental death anyway. More than two thousand people attended the funeral at the Elks lodge on West 43rd Street on 4 November, and he was buried at Machpelah Cemetery in Queens, at his mother's right hand, in the bronze casket he had been using on stage that season. Bess, raised a Catholic, could not join him there. When she died in 1943 she was buried in Westchester, and her name was cut on his monument instead.

Rosabelle, believe

The pact is the part everyone remembers and the part most often garbled, so here is what it actually was. Houdini had made agreements with several friends that whoever died first would try to get a message to the other, and he had spent years listening to mediums deliver messages from dead people that could have been written by anyone. The arrangement with Bess was designed to be unforgeable. It had two parts. The first word was Rosabelle, the name of the song she had been singing in her act at Coney Island when they met in 1894, and the word engraved inside her wedding ring. The rest was a word spelled out in the cipher they had used on stage.

In the Houdinis' mind-reading act, ten ordinary words stood for the digits one to ten: pray, answer, say, now, tell, please, speak, quickly, look, be quick. A letter was its position in the alphabet, so answer was B, tell was E, look was I, and a two-digit letter took two words: pray answer was twelve, L, and answer answer was twenty-two, V. The message Bess was waiting for was therefore: Rosabelle, answer, tell, pray answer, look, tell, answer answer, tell. Rosabelle, believe. She offered ten thousand dollars to any medium who could deliver it, and she sat for him every year, with his photograph and a light burning beside it.

Fletcher speaks

Arthur Ford was the pastor of the First Spiritualist Church of New York and the possessor of a spirit control called Fletcher, who did his talking for him. He approached the problem in two stages. In 1927 Bess had told a reporter from the Brooklyn Eagle that Houdini had longed to hear from his mother, and that any genuine message from her would contain the word 'forgive'. On 8 February 1928 Fletcher delivered the word 'forgive', from Houdini's mother, and Ford's associates carried it to Bess, who confirmed it was what she had been waiting for. Nobody at the time seems to have pointed out that she had announced it in a newspaper the year before.

The second stage took eleven months. In the first week of January 1929 Ford's friend Francis Fast brought word that Fletcher was ready with the code itself. Bess had fallen down a flight of stairs a few days earlier and was in bed with influenza and whatever her doctors had given her; a reporter who saw her described her as semi-delirious. The séance was held at her house in Inwood, at the top of Manhattan, on 8 January. Fletcher produced the ten words, in order, and asked Bess to take off her wedding ring and sing Rosabelle, which she did. Then he explained that the message meant 'believe', that Houdini now wished to be reconciled with the Spiritualists he had spent his life attacking, and that the code had been given to prove it. Ford's party had a statement typed up declaring the message correct, and Bess signed it. 'I had no idea what combination of words Harry would use,' she told the New York World the next day, 'and when he said believe, it was a surprise.'

It took the New York Evening Graphic two days. On 10 January its editor, Edward Churchill, called the séance a monumental hoax, and the following evening his reporter Rea Jaure invited Ford to her apartment and confronted him with a copy of a letter, delivered to Bess by Ford's associates two days before the sitting, that listed the ten words Fletcher was about to receive. Churchill and the managing editor, William Plummer, were listening from the next room, and all three signed sworn statements that Ford had offered Jaure money to 'play ball' and admitted he could not get the code from the spirits. Ford denied everything and said the Graphic was blackmailing him. In April the magazine Science and Invention printed Jaure's copy of the letter and a floor plan of the apartment showing where the editors had hidden.

The detail that settles it, though, needs no hidden editors. The code was not a secret. Harold Kellock's authorised biography, Houdini: His Life Story, written from Bess's own papers and published in 1928, the year before the séance, laid out the stage cipher and the pact. Anyone with a library card could have spelled 'believe' in it. Bess's lawyer, Bernard Ernst, said she had been drugged and grieving and 'not in a position to know what she was doing', and over the following years she disowned the whole episode, blaming what she called a sick brain. Ford never claimed the ten thousand dollars, never used Houdini again, and went on to become the most famous medium in America.

The roof of the Knickerbocker

By the mid-1930s Bess was living in Hollywood with her manager and companion Edward Saint, a former carnival showman who had made promoting Houdini's memory into a full-time job, and it was Saint who decided that the tenth anniversary needed an ending worthy of the name. He tried and failed to get the lights of Broadway dimmed for a minute. He did get the roof of the Knickerbocker Hotel on Ivar Street, carpeted and set with bleachers, with the Hollywoodland sign on the hills behind the table and about three hundred gold-printed invitations sent to guests and press.

The séance of 31 October 1936 began that evening with Pomp and Circumstance, the music that had opened Houdini's full-evening show. On the table lay a pair of locked handcuffs on a silk cushion, a trumpet and a tambourine. At the table, among the inner circle of magicians, sat a Los Angeles judge, Charles Fricke, and a past president of the state's Spiritualist association. Between Bess and Saint stood a small box they called the Houdini shrine, holding his portrait under a ruby light, the only light left burning on the roof. For more than an hour Saint pleaded with the dark. 'Are you here, Houdini?' 'Speak, Harry!' The handcuffs stayed locked. The Library of Congress holds the script, because the whole thing, like a good stage show, had been written in advance.

At the end Saint turned to Bess. The zero hour had passed, the ten years were up, had she reached a decision? Her answer, read in a flat voice that was recorded and has been reissued more than once since: 'Houdini did not come through. My last hope is gone. I do not believe that Houdini can come back to me, or to anyone. It is finished. Good night, Harry.' She reached out and switched off the light. The one piece of evidence that night produced was reported by the magician William Larsen: after Bess had gone down, rain fell from a clear sky, soaked everyone left on the roof and stopped as suddenly as it had started. The newspapers did not mention it. Bess died on 11 February 1943, of a heart attack on an eastbound train near Needles, California, and the line usually attached to the séance belongs to that year rather than to the roof: ten years, she said, was long enough to wait for any man.

A century of empty chairs

She had meant it as an ending. It became a franchise. Walter B. Gibson, who had ghostwritten Houdini's books and went on to create The Shadow, kept sitting on Halloween, and the Houdini Museum in Scranton traces its Original Houdini Séance, run by the magician Dorothy Dietrich and her partner Dick Brookz, to his blessing. Houdini's brother Theodore, who performed as Hardeen, passed the duty to his young protégé Sidney Radner, a collector from Holyoke, Massachusetts, who registered the name Official Houdini Séance as a trademark and held one in a different city every year until he died in June 2011, aged ninety-one. His family carries the name on: Holyoke in 2011, Danvers in 2014, Appleton in 2024 and, tonight, the Magic Castle in Hollywood, after an auction of Houdini relics in the afternoon. In 1948 the two lineages were sitting at the same table; a photograph survives of Gibson and Radner together, waiting.

The grave got its own ritual. For decades the Society of American Magicians, of which Houdini was president when he died, gathered at Machpelah every 31 October to break a wand over the monument and recite that the curtain had at last been rung down. The crowds attracted vandals, who eventually smashed Houdini's bust with a sledgehammer and broke up the benches, and the cemetery now locks its gates on Halloween. The ceremony moved to early November, and the site was restored with money from David Copperfield, who also owns the seventeen pages Lady Doyle wrote in Atlantic City.

And then there is this afternoon. The house on West 113th Street has not held a séance for him in fifty-five years. Today it holds three, each limited to thirteen sitters, with Dietrich leading the one timed to the minute of his death and the proceeds going to cancer research and the repair of the house itself. In Detroit, the city where he died, the Historical Museum has an evening of magic and mystery. In Appleton they are dedicating a historical marker. In Budapest they have taken three days over it. If you are reading this on the day, somebody somewhere is asking him a question right now.

What the case file says

Look at the structure of the thing rather than the fog around it. Here is a test devised by the world's leading expert on how mediums cheat, specifically to defeat the ways they cheat. The success condition was fixed in advance and known to the one witness who mattered. The witness wanted, more than anything, for it to succeed, and said so publicly, repeatedly, with money attached. The test has now been run, in good faith and bad, every year for a hundred years by people who knew him, people who loved him and people who merely admired him. The total number of hits is one, and the one hit arrived eleven months after the answer was published in a book, via a man who was caught with the words written down before the sitting.

That is not a draw. It is as clean a negative result as this subject has ever produced, and it is worth being honest that it is the reason the sceptics love Houdini so much: he is the one case where the controls were good. The Fox sisters, whose rappings started all this in 1848, confessed and were not believed; the Cock Lane ghost went to the pillory; the Winchester legend was invented by a ticket office. Houdini simply set a lock, gave his wife the key, and has declined for a century to open it. If he could, he would have. Nobody who knew him doubted that.

None of that makes tonight foolish. The séance has become what the man himself was, a very good piece of theatre with an honest sceptic sitting in it, and we would rather have thirteen people in a dark room in Harlem asking a clear question than a thousand photographing orbs. If you are sitting anywhere tonight, in his house or your own, borrow his method. Decide before the lights go down what would count as an answer, write it down where you cannot change it, and log the time, the room and who was there. Then wait. If the handcuffs open, the record will be worth having. If they stay shut, you will be in a hundred years of good company. Stay safe, stay spooky.

Got a story of your own?

Log your sightings, attach your evidence, and put your haunt on the map.

Get Spookr