← Back to The Haunt Report
GhostsNov 9, 2026 · 11 min read

Were the Angels of Mons Real? How a Newspaper Short Story Became the Ghost of the Great War

On Wednesday morning at eleven o'clock Britain will stand still for two minutes, as it has every November since 1919, for the dead of the war that was supposed to end war. This blog does not usually mark the week, because the First World War left behind very few ghost stories of the kind we write about: named witnesses, a fixed place, a record to check. It left one that nearly everyone believed. In the spring and summer of 1915 a large part of the country was satisfied that angels, or St George, or a shining cloud, or a line of phantom archers, had stood between the British Army and the Germans at Mons and saved it. Sermons were preached on it. Books were written for and against it. A soldier swore to it before a justice of the peace. And a middle-aged Welsh journalist spent the whole of that year, and the next three decades, trying to get people to understand that he had invented the entire thing one Sunday in September and could prove it.

The Angels of Mons are worth a case file not because the story is mysterious but because it is not. Nearly every stage of its growth, from fiction to faith, is dated and printed. Ghost legends usually reach us finished, with the seams hidden, like the Bell Witch arriving seventy-five years after the fact or the Brown Lady fixed in one photograph. This one was assembled in public, in eleven months, by people who left their names on the pieces. If you want to know how a haunting is made, this is the clearest set of instructions on record.

Were the Angels of Mons real?

No, as far as anyone has ever been able to show. The Angels of Mons are supernatural figures said to have appeared between the British and German lines at the Battle of Mons on 23 August 1914, or during the retreat that followed, and to have protected the outnumbered British Expeditionary Force. No soldier who fought at Mons ever gave a first-hand, named, checkable account of seeing them. The only sworn statement ever published came from a man whose service record showed he was still in England at the time. The earliest trace of the story is a short story called The Bowmen, printed without a fiction label in the London Evening News on 29 September 1914, and every later version can be followed forward from it. The Society for Psychical Research investigated during 1915 and reported that it had found no first-hand testimony at all, and nothing at second hand that would justify believing anything supernatural had happened. The one document said to predate the story, a general's letter dated 5 September 1914, was published in 1931 and does not survive in his papers in that form.

Mons, Sunday 23 August 1914

The British Expeditionary Force had been in France for barely a fortnight when it met the German army for the first time. About eighty thousand men had crossed the Channel, a small and highly trained professional force sent to hold the left of the French line, and on the evening of 22 August the II Corps under General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien dug in along the Mons-Condé canal in southern Belgium, a straight industrial waterway lined with slag heaps, pit villages and bridges. The next morning was a Sunday. Church bells were ringing in Mons when the German First Army under Alexander von Kluck came down on the canal in strength, and for most of the day two British divisions held it against a force that outnumbered them by something like two to one.

The regulars fired their Lee-Enfields so fast that German accounts spoke of being met by massed machine guns, and the bridges were held, lost and blown through the afternoon. British casualties came to a little over sixteen hundred killed, wounded and missing, most of them in the salient where the canal looped round the town. It was, by the standards of what came later, a small battle. But the French Fifth Army on the right was already falling back, the German numbers were overwhelming, and that night the order came to retreat. The retreat lasted two weeks and covered something like two hundred miles, with a second stand at Le Cateau on 26 August, and it ended only when the Allies turned on the Marne in early September. Men marched for days on an hour or two of sleep, and some of them later remembered seeing things on the road that were not there.

At home the news arrived as a shock. The Times printed a despatch from Amiens on Sunday 30 August that described a broken and exhausted army, and for a week the country believed that the war might be lost before the autumn. That is the mood in which the story was written.

A short story in the Evening News

Arthur Machen was fifty-one, a Welshman from Caerleon, the author of The Great God Pan and a shelf of other strange fiction that had never earned him a living, and a jobbing writer on the Evening News, a London afternoon paper with a large circulation and no particular reputation for restraint. He said afterwards that the idea came to him in church on the Sunday he read the first accounts of the retreat. He sat down and wrote The Bowmen, and the paper printed it on Tuesday 29 September 1914.

The story is short and, by Machen's own later judgement, not very good. A nameless British soldier in a thinning line, facing a German attack that cannot be stopped, remembers a Latin motto he once saw printed round the figure of St George on the plates of a vegetarian restaurant in London: Adsit Anglis Sanctus Georgius, may St George be present to the English. He says it aloud. A shout goes up along the line, a long line of shapes with a shining about them appears, and the archers of Agincourt loose their arrows into the Germans by the thousand. The Germans fall. Afterwards the German General Staff, finding ten thousand dead without a wound on them, decides the English must have used shells containing an unknown poison gas.

That is the whole of it. The Evening News ran the piece as a column of ordinary copy, under Machen's byline but with nothing to mark it as fiction, and the first consequence was quiet. Within a month or two editors of parish magazines wrote asking to reprint it, and Machen agreed. Then one of them wrote back asking for his sources, so that the account could be published as a pamphlet. Machen replied that there were no sources, that he had made it up. The reply, which he quoted for the rest of his life with a kind of weary amazement, was that he must be mistaken, because the main facts of The Bowmen must be true, and he had merely elaborated a little on an actual event.

From archers to angels

For the whole of the winter the story circulated in that half-believed state, reprinted in church magazines and passed about by hand. In April 1915 it changed. The Hereford Times printed a piece headed A Troop of Angels, based on what a Miss Marrable, the daughter of Canon Marrable, was said to have been told by two officers: that their men had seen angels on the retreat, and that one of the officers, who did not believe in such things, had seen them himself. In May the parish magazine of All Saints, Clifton, in Bristol reprinted it, and from there it went everywhere. The spiritualist weekly Light had already announced on 24 April that the legend of Mons was fascinating and that it should like to hear more. In the May number of the Occult Review the theosophist A. P. Sinnett reported that those who could see had seen a row of shining beings between the two armies. By midsummer the shining beings were angels in every version, St George was in some, and the archers had almost disappeared.

Then people started trying to find the officers. When Miss Marrable was asked for their names she said she had been misquoted and did not know them; she had heard the story from others. Machen, by now being written to daily, pointed out that the sequence was exactly what he would have predicted: his bowmen had been described as shining, English readers of the Edwardian sort did not have a ready category for ghostly medieval archers but did have one for angels, and so the one had turned into the other. In August 1915 he published The Bowmen and Other Legends of the War, a slim book with a long introduction explaining the whole history and insisting there was nothing behind it. It sold better than anything else he ever wrote, and it did not make the slightest difference.

Instead it produced a reply. Harold Begbie, a journalist with a strong line in wartime uplift, brought out On the Side of the Angels before the year was out, accusing Machen of arrogance and of profiting from a true story he happened to have written down first, and asserting that Machen had been unconsciously inspired by the real events through telepathy from the battlefield. When Machen asked him to produce a single witness, Begbie answered that the soldiers were being kept quiet by the authorities. A nurse named Phyllis Campbell published Back of the Front the same year, reporting that wounded men she treated in France had seen St George and that the French had seen Joan of Arc and St Michael, and that she had written to the Occult Review about it before Machen's story ever appeared. The magazine never produced the letter, and she never named one of the men.

The strongest piece of evidence, at the time, was the affidavit. On 24 August 1915 the Daily Mail printed a statement sworn before a justice of the peace by Private Robert Cleaver of the 1st Cheshire Regiment, declaring that he had personally been at Mons and seen the vision of angels with his own eyes. The Cheshires had been at Mons, and had been badly cut up the next day at Audregnies. The following month the Mail checked his record and printed a correction: Cleaver had not left for France until 22 September 1914, a month after the battle. He was the only man ever to put his name to the story under oath.

The Society for Psychical Research looks for a witness

The Society for Psychical Research was founded to find exactly this sort of thing, and in 1915 it tried to. The enquiry was conducted by Helen Salter, born Helen Verrall, one of the Society's research officers, and her report was published in its Journal in December 1915. She wrote to the authors of the pamphlets and sermons, followed every chain of attribution back as far as it would go, and set out what she found. A large number of the stories could be traced directly to the Clifton parish magazine of May 1915. Every account that began as first-hand became second-hand on enquiry, and then third-hand, and then stopped at someone who had heard it from an officer whose name they did not know. The Cleaver affidavit was dealt with in a paragraph. Her conclusion was that the Society had found no first-hand testimony whatever, and nothing at second hand that would justify assuming anything supernormal had occurred.

It is worth being clear about who was saying this. The SPR of 1915 was not a sceptics' club. Its leading members believed in telepathy and were about to spend the 1920s investigating mediums with real hope. They wanted the angels to be real as much as anybody in the country, and they were the only people who went looking properly. They came back with nothing.

The general's letter

The one document that is still produced to show the story predates Machen appeared in 1931. Brigadier-General John Charteris, who had been Haig's chief of intelligence, published At G.H.Q., a book presented as his wartime letters home and diary entries. An entry dated 5 September 1914 says that the story of the Angels of Mons was going strong through the 2nd Corps. If that was written on 5 September, the angels were in the army three weeks before the Evening News printed a word.

There are three problems. Charteris was not with II Corps in 1914; he was on Haig's I Corps staff, which had barely been engaged at Mons. His own preface admits the book was not a diary but a reconstruction, with gaps in the letters amplified from recollection. And when the folklorist David Clarke went through the Charteris papers for his 2004 study of the legend, he found no letter dated 5 September and no letter from 1914 mentioning angels at all. The entry is best read as a memory written down seventeen years later and dated backwards, by a man whose professional business in the war had been shaping what the enemy and the public believed. Charteris is also the officer whose name is attached, rightly or wrongly, to the 1917 story that the Germans were rendering their dead for fat. Clarke has suggested that intelligence officers may have quietly encouraged the angel stories in 1915 as a boost to morale. That is a hypothesis, not a finding, and it should be weighed as one. But the only paper trail that would place the angels before the story was written out by a propagandist from memory, and that is not a paper trail.

The film that never existed

The legend had one more growth spurt, and it is the most instructive of all because it happened within living memory. In March 2001 the Sunday Times reported that Marlon Brando and the director Tony Kaye had paid three hundred and fifty thousand pounds for a trunk of material found in a junk shop in Monmouth by a Gloucestershire architect named Danny Sullivan: the diary of a Mons veteran called William Doidge, together with film footage of an angel he had gone on to capture years later in the grounds of Woodchester Park. The story went round the world. Sullivan had written a book about Woodchester Mansion, an unfinished Victorian ruin in the park, and gave interviews about the find.

No one outside the story ever saw the footage, or the diary, or any record of a William Doidge. In 2002 Sullivan told a BBC Radio 4 documentary, The Making of an Urban Myth, that he had invented the soldier, the diary and the film to drum up interest in the mansion. The Brando purchase had never happened. Eighty-seven years after Machen, the Angels of Mons had been faked a second time, and a national newspaper had again printed it without asking to see the evidence.

What the case file says

Lay the dated pieces in a row and you have the complete life cycle of a legend. A short story is printed without a label on 29 September 1914. It is reprinted as fact by people who assume a newspaper would not print fiction as news. The writer's denial is treated as modesty, or error, or a cover-up. In April 1915 it acquires witnesses, unnamed officers vouched for by a clergyman's daughter who, when asked, cannot name them. In May a parish magazine gives it national reach. The spiritualist and occult press, which has a motive, picks it up. By August a man who was not there swears to it, and when he is found out the finding does not travel as far as the oath did. A rebuttal book accuses the debunker of being the liar. Sixteen years later a general's memoir dates it backwards. Ninety years after that, a hoaxer sells a national newspaper a film that does not exist. Every step is a thing a decent, sincere person could do without lying, except the affidavit and the film.

The lessons for anyone who logs a sighting are the same ones this blog keeps arriving at from different directions. A friend of an officer is not a witness. A story that gets more detailed each time it is told is getting worse, not better. If you saw something, write it down with the time, the place and your own name before you have read anyone else's version, because the version you read will become the version you remember. And if the account you are checking starts in a newspaper, look at what else was on the page. Ghostwatch did this to a generation in ninety-one minutes in 1992. The Evening News did it to a country in a single column, and the man who wrote it, who went on protesting until he died in 1947, is one of the few people in this whole subject who told the exact truth from beginning to end and was disbelieved for it.

None of this touches the men on the canal. Some of the Cheshires who were really at Mons were dead within a day at Audregnies, and their names are on the memorial at La Ferté-sous-Jouarre with the rest of the retreat's missing. The record of Mons is the casualty list, not the sky, and it is the one worth two minutes of silence on Wednesday. Stay safe, stay spooky.

Got a story of your own?

Log your sightings, attach your evidence, and put your haunt on the map.

Get Spookr