← Back to The Haunt Report
GhostsOct 17, 2026 · 9 min read

Is the Winchester Mystery House Really Haunted? The Case File on Sarah Winchester

Every ghost tour has a house like this one, and this is the house the rest of them are copied from. You walk in under the sign in San Jose, California, and a guide tells you that Sarah Winchester, widow of the rifle heir, was told by a medium that the spirits of everyone killed by a Winchester would hunt her down unless she kept hammers swinging day and night for the rest of her life. So she built for thirty-eight years without stopping: doors that open onto walls, a staircase that climbs into a ceiling, thirteen of everything, a séance room where she took the spirits' orders for the next day's carpentry. Then you buy the ticket.

The house is real, and genuinely strange, and worth the visit. Almost nothing else in that paragraph survives contact with the record. What the record shows instead is a story this blog has told before in other costumes: a private person, a hostile press, a disaster that was later mistaken for a design, and a business that discovered it could sell a haunting. The difference is that here the business has been selling it for a hundred and three years, which is long enough for the sales pitch to turn into history.

What is the Winchester Mystery House?

The Winchester Mystery House is a sprawling Victorian mansion at 525 South Winchester Boulevard in San Jose, built up from an eight-room farmhouse by Sarah Lockwood Pardee Winchester between 1886 and the 1906 earthquake, with occasional work afterwards until her death in 1922. At the time of her death it had about 160 rooms, around 2,000 doors, 10,000 windows, 47 staircases and 47 fireplaces. It has been open for paid tours since June 1923 and is run as a private business by the descendants of the family who leased it that year.

The haunted-house story attached to it has three parts: that Sarah Winchester built to appease the ghosts of people killed by Winchester rifles, that she built continuously on the instructions of a medium, and that the house's odd features were meant to confuse spirits. None of the three can be traced to her, to anyone who knew her, or to any document from her lifetime. That is the short answer. The long answer is better.

Sarah Pardee of New Haven

Sarah Lockwood Pardee was born in New Haven, Connecticut, in 1839, and was known to her family all her life as Sallie. On 30 September 1862 she married William Wirt Winchester, son of Oliver Winchester, whose company would put its name on the rifle that sold the American West to itself. In the summer of 1866 she had a daughter, Annie, who died within weeks of a wasting disease the doctors called marasmus. Oliver Winchester died in December 1880. William died of tuberculosis in March 1881.

She did not inherit twenty million dollars, a figure that turns up in most retellings and that no document supports. Her husband left her 777 shares in the Winchester Repeating Arms Company, valued at the time at a little under 78,000 dollars, and the dividends on them ran to about 7,900 dollars a year through the early 1880s. In 1898 she inherited two thousand more shares from her mother-in-law. It was a fortune, but a fortune of the ordinary kind, and when she died her estate was valued at three to four million dollars, far below the rumours.

In 1885 she went west, on medical advice for the arthritis that would bend her hands and keep her in gloves and a veil for the rest of her life, and in 1886 she bought a 45-acre ranch outside San Jose with an unfinished eight-room farmhouse on it, for 12,570 dollars. She named it Llanada Villa. The plan, as far as her letters show one, was a house big enough for her sisters and their families to join her. By 1890 her niece Marion, known as Daisy, had moved in, and the two women would live there together until Daisy married in 1903.

Building without a plan

Sarah Winchester was her own architect. She had no training, drew her plans on paper and tablecloths, and changed her mind often, which is the honest origin of most of what the tours now point at. A room would be framed, then abandoned when a better idea arrived, and because she disliked waste the leftover gaps became cupboards and closets. A door that opens onto a drop of several feet is where an extension was planned and never finished. The famous switchback staircase, forty-four steps that climb about ten feet, has risers only a couple of inches high: it was built for a woman whose knees could no longer manage an ordinary stair.

By the late 1890s the house had seven storeys and a tower. A San Jose paper reported in 1897 that the tower had been pulled down and rebuilt sixteen times, which is the kind of claim a newspaper makes about an eccentric rich neighbour rather than one it has counted. What her own correspondence shows, as the historian Mary Jo Ignoffo found when she wrote the first serious biography, Captive of the Labyrinth, in 2010, is that construction was nothing like continuous. Winchester sent her crews away for months at a time, and the work slowed to almost nothing after 1906.

The men who built it liked her. A 1951 master's thesis at San Jose State that interviewed surviving workers found an employer who gave paid days off when the heat was too bad to work, kept staff for decades, bought homes for some of them and remembered them in her will. None of the workers interviewed mentioned ghosts, séances or spirits. The stained glass that the tours credit to Tiffany was mostly the work of a San Francisco decorator, John Mallon's Pacific American Decorative Company; in 2019, renovators opening a wall found one of the firm's envelopes, postmarked July 1894.

The newspapers get there first

The local press did not like her. She was an Eastern millionaire who kept to herself, did not entertain, and spent conspicuously on a house nobody was invited to see, and San Jose in the 1890s had opinions about that. On 29 March 1895 the San Jose Evening News ran a story under the headline 'A Woman Who Thinks She Will Die When Her House Is Built'. That is the earliest known printed version of the legend, and it is worth noticing what it contains and what it does not. It has the building, and the fear of death. It has no medium, no rifle victims, no number thirteen and no séance room. Those would take another seventy years to arrive.

The 1895 story was picked up in San Francisco the same year, and by 1911 the San Francisco Examiner was calling Llanada Villa a 'House of Mystery'. Sarah Winchester never answered any of it. The silence that was supposed to prove she had something to hide is, read the other way, exactly what a private woman with painful hands and a dislike of newspapers would do.

18 April 1906

At twelve minutes past five in the morning the San Francisco earthquake took the top off the house. The seven-storey tower came down, the third- and fourth-floor additions collapsed, and most of the chimneys fell. Winchester had the rubble cleared, the damaged sections boarded off and the house made safe, and then she stopped. The only significant later addition was an elevator in 1916, for the same reason as the shallow stairs. She spent most of the rest of her life at a house in Atherton, and the local papers, which had called her mad for building, now called her mad for not rebuilding.

This is the fact that the whole legend is built around and never mentions. The doors that open onto nothing open onto places where rooms used to be. The staircase into the ceiling climbs towards a floor that fell down in 1906. The house as it stands today is the lower part of a larger house, sealed up by its owner after a disaster and never finished, and when you know that, the 'built to confuse the spirits' story stops being mysterious and starts being slightly embarrassing.

Six months after the funeral

Sarah Winchester died at Llanada Villa on 5 September 1922, aged eighty-three, and was buried in New Haven beside her husband and daughter. Her will divided her money among relatives, long-serving staff and charities, with the biggest gifts going to tuberculosis care in New Haven, the disease that had killed William. Nobody in it was a medium. The house was appraised as practically worthless, in poor repair and odd enough that only the land was thought to have value, and the estate auctioned it that December.

In April 1923 the new owners leased the house to John and Mayme Brown, who had a different idea of its value. On 30 June 1923, less than ten months after the funeral, the Browns opened it for paid tours, with Mayme as the first guide. They bought the property outright in 1931, their descendants own it still, and the company they formed in 1963 runs it today. Every version of the Winchester story that you have heard was told, in the first instance, by someone with a ticket to sell.

The ghost-hunting world's patron sceptic turned up early. Harry Houdini was in San Jose on 29 October 1924 for one of his lectures against fraudulent mediums, at the Victory Theatre, and an employee of the house who had helped him on stage took him and his wife Bess through it that night by lamplight. The house keeps a newspaper clipping he signed. The 'Mystery House' name was in regular use by the 1930s, and the business has always been happy to let visitors believe Houdini suggested it. Whether he did or not, he came as a debunker, not a believer, and he would be dead within two years, on Halloween night 1926, a date this blog will come back to in a fortnight.

Where each piece of the legend comes from

The rest of the story can be dated, piece by piece, and every date is after 1922. The séance room first appears in a 1928 promotional article. The guides later settled on a small room called the Blue Room, which the surviving staff identified as the head gardener's room. Sarah Winchester's spiritualism is mentioned by nobody who knew her: not her lawyer, not her chauffeur, not her staff, not her niece, and not her letters.

The number thirteen entered the story in 1929, in a magazine article called 'The Strangest House in the World', seven years after her death. A carpenter who had worked on the house, James Perkins, said in a 1983 interview that the thirteen-themed details had been added after she died, and Ignoffo noted in 2013 that the set of thirteen coat hooks on the tour had been installed within the previous five years. The only thirteens that appear to go back to Winchester herself are a few floral drain covers in the sinks.

The Boston medium, usually given the name Adam Coons, and the spirits of the rifle dead with their instruction to build forever arrive last of all. They first appear in print in 1967, in a popular book called Prominent American Ghosts by Susy Smith, forty-five years after Winchester's death and more than eighty after the supposed consultation. Researchers have searched the Boston city directories and the Banner of Light, the spiritualist newspaper of the day, for a medium of that name and found none. There is no record of Sarah Winchester consulting any medium, in Boston or anywhere else.

The smaller furniture of the legend goes the same way. President Theodore Roosevelt was not turned away at her front gate in 1903; his carriage drove past, and she was renting a house near San Francisco that spring for Daisy's wedding. The safe that was supposed to hold gold plates for her nightly dinners with the spirits held, when the Browns opened it, a lock of her baby's hair and some mementoes of her husband. The investigator Joe Nickell went through all of this in 2002 and reached the same verdict every historian since has reached: the Winchester Mystery House is a remarkable building with a fabricated biography attached.

Is the Winchester Mystery House haunted?

There is no evidence that it is. The house has been running tours for a century, flashlight tours since the 1980s and ghost-themed events every October, and in all that time it has produced the same evidence as every other large old wooden building full of visitors: cold spots, which are draughts in a house with 10,000 windows; creaks and footsteps, which are a timber frame settling; and photographs of orbs, which are dust in the flash. The house was used as a location for the 1960 film 13 Ghosts, inspired Disney's Haunted Mansion in 1969, and in 2018 got a film of its own, Winchester, with Helen Mirren, sold as 'based on a true story'. Ignoffo, who knows the story better than anyone alive, has said plainly that it is not.

What the house does have is a hundred and three years of people being told it is haunted before they walk in. If you want to test what that does to an ordinary afternoon in an ordinary building, the Winchester house is the best laboratory in the world, and that is a reason to go.

Why this one is worth carrying

The Bell Witch legend has a seventy-five-year gap between the events and the first account of them. Borley Rectory had Harry Price, who needed the house to be haunted for the sake of his books. The Winchester house is both at once: a story whose every supernatural element can be dated to a press office, decades after the only witness who mattered had died without ever telling it.

The practical lesson is about provenance, and it is the same one this blog keeps arriving at. Before you ask whether a story is true, ask when it was first written down, by whom, and what they were selling. A claim that first appears in 1967 about a woman who died in 1922 is not a weak piece of evidence. It is not evidence at all. And when you log your own visit somewhere, record the building as you found it, not as the guide described it. A door that opens onto a wall is a fact. Why it does is a question, and the answer, more often than anyone would like, is an earthquake. Stay safe, stay spooky.

Got a story of your own?

Log your sightings, attach your evidence, and put your haunt on the map.

Get Spookr