← Back to The Haunt Report
RetroSep 26, 2026 · 10 min read

Based on a True Case: The Scariest Paranormal Films, Checked Against the Files

Every October the same argument comes round: what is the scariest film ever made? For five years now a British price-comparison site, of all things, has been trying to settle it with instruments. The Science of Scare project sits a panel of around 250 people in front of the usual suspects, puts heart-rate monitors on them, and ranks the films by how far pulses climb and how ragged the beat gets. In the 2025 results the top of the table is Sinister, Scott Derrickson's 2012 film about a true-crime writer and a box of home movies, with a Scare Score of 96 out of 100 and an average heart-rate uplift of about a third.

That is a checkable claim about fear, which is more than most lists offer. But it measures what a film does to a body in ninety minutes, not what is underneath it. And a striking share of the films on that table, and on every other list you will read this month, open with the same four words: based on a true story. Two of the panel's top ten do. So did the poster for The Amityville Horror, and the cover of the book before it.

This is a case-file blog, so we have done the thing nobody does with those four words, which is take them literally. Below are the paranormal films that lean hardest on a real case, in an order that has nothing to do with heart rate and everything to do with what the file actually says. The first two are there because they are the ones people keep asking us about, and because they are the two where the gap between the film and the record is widest, in opposite directions.

1. The Entity (1982)

The film. Barbara Hershey plays Carla Moran, a single mother in Los Angeles who is attacked in her own bed by something nobody can see. A psychiatrist, Ron Silver's Dr Sneiderman, decides it is trauma. A team of parapsychologists decides it is not, and the film ends with them building a replica of her house and freezing the thing with liquid helium, briefly, before it breaks loose. Sidney J. Furie directed, from Frank De Felitta's script of his own 1978 novel. Martin Scorsese put it fourth on his 2009 list of the eleven scariest films ever made, above Psycho and The Shining, and singled out the banal settings for making it worse. He is right. The most frightening room in the film is a bathroom.

The file. In August 1974 a woman named Doris Bither struck up a conversation in a Los Angeles bookshop with Barry Taff, a field investigator for the parapsychology lab that Thelma Moss ran on the fifth floor of UCLA's Neuropsychiatric Institute. Bither said she was being attacked in her home in Culver City by something she could not see. Taff and his colleague Kerry Gaynor made their first visit on 22 August 1974 and kept coming back for about ten weeks. The house was small, condemned and in poor repair, and Bither was living in it illegally with her four children.

What the investigators reported is, on paper, extraordinary: cold spots, foul smells, a frying pan leaving a cupboard on its own, and above all lights, greenish and floating, that they described as expanding and contracting and that at one session were said to have built up into the upper part of a figure. They photographed the lights with a Polaroid SX-70 and a 35mm camera, and two prints show bright arcs of light framing a woman on the bed. Frank De Felitta was in the house for at least one of these sessions, and Bither stayed in touch with him after she had lost contact with the lab. He wrote the novel. Taff was technical adviser on the film.

Now the part the film could not use. By the later sessions there were twenty or thirty people crammed into that house, and the record is clear that only three of them, Taff, Gaynor and Bither, consistently reported seeing anything unusual. The infrared film was overexposed and useless. In 2021 the investigator Kenny Biddle went back over the surviving photographs for the Skeptical Inquirer and noted that the woman in the Polaroids was not Bither at all but a psychic friend, that the 'entity' frames were shot with flash and the control frames without, and that the famous arcs of light are exactly what a strand of hair close to a flash lens produces. He reproduced them with his wife's hair. Bither, by her own account to the team, had a childhood of abuse behind her and a great deal of trouble in front of her. Taff, to his credit, wrote that down too.

So what did the film change? Almost everything that gives it a shape. There was no trap, no helium, no moment where the thing became visible to a room full of scientists. There was a distressed woman in a condemned house, two investigators who believed her, a crowd who mostly saw nothing, and photographs that do not survive a second look. The family moved, to Carson, to San Bernardino, eventually to Texas, and Bither told De Felitta the disturbances went with her. She died in the late 1990s. Taff still says, fifty years on, that it was 'the real deal,' and Gaynor's conclusion was that whatever was happening was coming from Bither herself. That is the strangest thing about the case: the film's closing card, which says the attacks continued at reduced frequency after the family left, is the most accurate sentence in it.

2. The Exorcism of Emily Rose (2005)

The film. Scott Derrickson again, seven years before Sinister. Jennifer Carpenter plays Emily, a college student who dies after an exorcism; Tom Wilkinson plays the priest tried for negligent homicide over her death; Laura Linney is his agnostic defence lawyer. It is a courtroom drama with a horror film cut into it as testimony, and it keeps two explanations, epilepsy and possession, in play until the end, when the jury convicts and asks for a sentence of time served. It made 145 million dollars on a 19 million budget, and it is the ninth scariest film on the 2025 Science of Scare table, the only one in that top ten with a real trial behind it.

The file. Anneliese Michel was born in 1952 in Leiblfing, Bavaria, to a devout Catholic family, and had her first seizure at sixteen. The diagnosis was temporal lobe epilepsy, and over the next few years she was prescribed Dilantin, then an antipsychotic, then Tegretol. By 1973 she was depressed, hearing voices telling her she was damned, and seeing what she called devil faces. She could no longer bear crucifixes. Two priests, Ernst Alt and the Salvatorian Arnold Renz, became convinced she was possessed, and in August 1975 the Bishop of Würzburg, Josef Stangl, authorised the rite of exorcism from the Rituale Romanum, a text dating to 1614.

The first session was on 24 September 1975. There were sixty-seven of them, once or twice a week, some running four hours, and the priests recorded many of them on tape. By the last months Anneliese was refusing food, genuflecting until her knees gave way, and had contracted pneumonia. She died on 1 July 1976 in her parents' house in Klingenberg am Main. She weighed thirty kilograms. The cause was malnutrition and dehydration, and the prosecutor's case was that a doctor could have saved her as late as a week before.

The trial opened in Aschaffenburg on 30 March 1978 with four defendants, the two priests and both parents. Her body had been exhumed five weeks earlier. On 21 April all four were convicted of negligent homicide and given six-month sentences, suspended, with three years' probation. Nobody went to prison. Cardinal Ratzinger, then Archbishop of Munich, said the ritual 'must be thoroughly revised,' and the German bishops ruled that no exorcism would proceed without a doctor's examination. Anneliese's mother, interviewed in 2006, still said they had done the right thing.

What the film changed is the point of view. It moves the story to America, cuts the four defendants to one priest, and gives him a lawyer who slowly comes to doubt her own doubt. It lets the jury do what juries in horror films do, which is find a way to acquit the supernatural. The Aschaffenburg court did the opposite: it decided, on medical evidence, that a young woman with a treatable illness had been allowed to starve while the adults around her prayed. Where The Entity inflates a thin file into a monster, Emily Rose takes the thickest file on this list, an actual conviction, and makes it ambiguous. Watch it this month, by all means. Then remember that the real ambiguity was resolved in a courtroom in 1978, and not in the film's favour.

3. The Exorcist (1973)

William Friedkin's film needs no introduction and has slipped out of the heart-rate panel's top ten, which says more about fifty years of imitations than about the film. Its source is a case we touched on in the Ouija board post. In January 1949 a fourteen-year-old boy in Cottage City, Maryland, from a German Lutheran family, began to be troubled by scratching in the walls and moving furniture, not long after his aunt Harriet, a spiritualist, had introduced him to the talking board. Over the following months he was taken to Georgetown University Hospital, then to relatives in St Louis, where a group of Jesuits led by William Bowdern performed the rite over several weeks, finishing at the Alexian Brothers Hospital in April. One of them, Raymond Bishop, kept a diary. In August 1949 the Washington Post ran a story about it, and a Georgetown student named William Peter Blatty read the story.

The boy's name was kept out of everything until 2021, when the Skeptical Inquirer identified him as Ronald Hunkeler, who had died the year before after a long and quiet career as an engineer. The journalist Mark Opsasnick, who spent the 1990s tracking down the neighbours and classmates, concluded that 'much of the commonly accepted information about this story is based on hearsay, is not documented, and was never fact-checked.' Walter Halloran, the last surviving priest from the St Louis sessions, told him that the boy's Latin sounded like mimicry, that the marks on his skin looked 'more like lipstick' than blood, and, when asked to state for the record that the boy had been possessed: 'No, I can't go on record. I never made an absolute statement about the things because I didn't feel I was qualified.' What the film changed: the boy became a girl, the Ouija board stayed, and a priest's diary became the most influential horror novel of the century.

4. The Conjuring (2013) and The Conjuring 2 (2016)

James Wan's first Conjuring film is fifth on the heart-rate table, and it is the one where the true-story claim does the most work in the marketing and the least in the film. The Perron family, Roger and Carolyn and five daughters, moved into a farmhouse in Harrisville, Rhode Island, in January 1971 and stayed until 1980, and Carolyn Perron reported the standard low-grade poltergeist inventory: a broom that went missing, piles of dirt on a freshly cleaned floor, scraping sounds in the kitchen. Bathsheba Sherman was a real woman, born Bathsheba Thayer in 1812, who lived nearby in the nineteenth century. The story that she killed a child and practised witchcraft is a rumour; there was no charge and no trial. Andrea Perron, the eldest daughter, who has written three volumes about the house and believes it was haunted, has said the film is about 95 percent fiction and 5 percent truth, and that the family came to think the presence was not Bathsheba at all. That is the family's own witness, and she is harder on the film than we need to be.

The sequel is built on the Enfield case, which readers of this blog know well. There the record is thick. Maurice Grosse and Guy Lyon Playfair logged the better part of two thousand incidents over fourteen months, and the film simply puts the wrong people in the middle of them. Playfair said in 2016 that the Warrens 'turned up once,' uninvited, stayed a day, and that Ed Warren told him they could make a lot of money out of the case. The Enfield file is one of the best in the world. The film about it stars two people who were barely in it.

5. The Amityville Horror (1979)

The one where the true-story claim was on the book jacket. On 13 November 1974 Ronald DeFeo Jr shot his parents and four siblings in their beds at 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville. Thirteen months later George and Kathy Lutz bought the house, stayed twenty-eight days, and left. Jay Anson's 1977 book and Stuart Rosenberg's 1979 film turned those twenty-eight days into flies in winter, green slime down the walls and a pig with red eyes at the window. In September 1979, with the film still in cinemas, DeFeo's defence lawyer William Weber told People magazine: 'I know this book's a hoax. We created this horror story over many bottles of wine.' He was in a position to know. He had been hoping a haunting would help his client's appeal. The Lutzes took polygraphs and insisted on their story for the rest of their lives. The Warrens investigated this one too. What the film changed is beside the point. The story had been changed before it ever reached a screenwriter.

6. The Changeling (1980)

Peter Medak's film about a composer, George C. Scott, alone in a Seattle mansion with a bouncing ball and a dead boy's wheelchair is the best-made film on this list, and the one whose true story dissolves fastest when you pull on it. The composer Russell Hunter, who co-wrote the story, said that from 9 February 1969 the house he rented near Cheesman Park in Denver produced 'unbelievable banging and crashing' every morning at six, that a séance led him to a hidden room and the story of a murdered child, and that the child's family had covered it up. The Denver Public Library went looking. Its archivists found that Hunter did live in Denver at the end of the 1960s, could find no record that he ever lived at the Henry Treat Rogers mansion, and could find no record of the boy. The house has since been demolished. The séance scene is still the best one ever filmed. On the available evidence it is also the only séance in the story.

The one that is not on the list

Ghostwatch is not based on a case. It is the case, and we have covered it. It belongs here as the control: the only film on this page that told its audience it was fiction, in the listings and in the credits, and was believed anyway. Every 'based on a true story' card above is a weaker version of the same trick, run in the other direction.

What the files have in common

Line the six up and one pattern falls out. In every case the film adds an ending. The Entity gets a trap. Emily Rose gets a verdict the real court did not give. The Exorcist gets a rite that works. The Conjuring gets a witch with a name. Amityville gets a family fleeing in the night, and The Changeling gets a fire. The files themselves end the way files end: a family moves, a court adjourns, an archivist writes 'no record found.' The fear in the films is real; the panel's heart monitors prove that much. What is borrowed is the resolution, and the resolution is the part that never happened.

None of which is an argument against watching them. Watch them; it is the season. But when the card comes up at the start, treat it the way you would treat a claim in a report on the MYSTMAP: as a lead, not a finding. Go and read the file afterwards. The Bither photographs are online, the Aschaffenburg verdict is a matter of record, Opsasnick's interviews are in print, and Playfair's account of Enfield is a book you can hold. And if you are out this October and something happens that would make a good scene, remember what every case above has in common at its start. Somebody in a bad situation saw something, told someone, and nobody wrote it down properly until years later. Log it that night, with the time, the place, and the unedited original. That is the one thing every one of these films was missing. Stay safe, stay spooky.

Got a story of your own?

Log your sightings, attach your evidence, and put your haunt on the map.

Get Spookr